Opinion: Stick Shift Memories – Are They Fading?
By Chad Waite | April 18, 2010
Do you remember when you first learned how to drive stick shift? We sure do! It was a magical time, coupled with a moment of triumph when you realized that you could hop in and take off. Do you remember practicing at every stop, priding yourself on a flawless, smooth start? Do you remember how it felt while accelerating hard to throw it into 3rd and feel the speed gather around you? The fact is, if you ever learned how to drive stick, you have experienced these sublime memories. Now, sadly, things are changing, and the third pedal is becoming a relic of the past.
The appearance of fast-changing paddle shifters in F1 racers was the first sign that the future of manual gearboxes was dwindling. Manual was always the choice of racers because of the superb amount of control it provided as well as the ability to modulate the clutch to bring around the back end of the car. Over the last 10 years technology has improved so much on manumatics, that manuals are now outclassed.
The virtues of stick shifts included, but certainly weren’t limited to:
· Improved performance
· Better gas mileage
· Driver engagement
· Extra gears
· Light weight
· Low cost
· Simplicity
· Multi-gear downshifts
· And it’s just plain fun!
The problem is that a computer can select a gear much faster than a human can depress the clutch, throw the stick in gear, and release the clutch. In a race where the winner will cross the finish line .08 seconds before the runner up, you can’t leave in human error.
The last nail in the coffin for stick-shift purists came last month when Ferrari announced it would no longer offer the 3rd pedal. Lamborghini followed suit at the end of the month with the same announcement. If the most enjoyable cars to feel a visceral connection to are moving away from stick in lieu of better performance and efficiency in engineering, then the world will be a different place in just a matter of years.
Gone are the days of push starting a car with a bad starter or battery, and here are the days of men finding other rites of passage besides learning stick. It’s a sad time, but we must admit defeat for clutch-driver synergy.
One thing still brings joy to our souls – stick shift is still the chosen transmission by stunt drivers. Weigh in with your comments. How much longer do you think before the likes of Honda, Toyota, and Ford go the way of the paddle, and ditch the stick forever?





5 Comments
stephk on April 18, 2010 at 4:14 pm.
When I went car shopping a few years ago, one of the sales guys told me that “they don’t really make manual transmission cars anymore.” The CTS-V had just come out on the scene. I laughed in his face and left the lot.
I insist on having stick shift. I hope it never completely goes away. You’re not driving otherwise…. just riding and steering. You’d think they’d at least make something for the enthusiasts and others who feel like I do. They’re crazy if they don’t. IMO, that’s still a good chunk of the driving population.
Chad Waite on April 18, 2010 at 4:40 pm.
“The CTS-V had just come out on the scene. I laughed in his face and left the lot.”
Oh man, that’s funny. I totally agree with you. I know tons of people who drive stick and still want to, including myself.
FB_1234097888 on April 18, 2010 at 8:22 pm.
The large majority of MINIs that are produced have sticks, something like 80%. They are fighting the good fight.
Derek on April 19, 2010 at 5:34 pm.
If you love manuals take a trip to Eastern Europe where automatics are seen as “sissy boy” cars. In fact steering and braking systems are manual as well. Taxi drivers turn their Russian junkers completely off when they are going down hills to save on gas… Makes for a quiet ride.
Michelle on April 20, 2010 at 3:57 am.
So…is this going to make stick shift driving easier? I have yet to perfect it.